What Do You Think of Supreme Court Ruling on Affirmative Action?

What Do You Think of Supreme Court Ruling on Affirmative Action?

Is the future of affirmative action programs in jeopardy? On Tuesday, the Supreme Court upheld a Michigan law that bans race as a factor in college admissions.

Sept. 16, 2006 - Lansing, Michigan, L- Members of the NAACP march to the Michigan state capitol to oppose Proposal 2 on the November ballot. R- Students counter-demonstrated NAACP march.

The high court ruled 6-2, with Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Ruth Bader Ginsburg dissenting. Justice Elena Kagan did not vote. Here’s an excerpt of Sotomayor’s dissenting opinion, in which credits affirmative action for "opening doors" for her own life:

“Race matters. Race matters in part because of the long history of racial minorities’ being denied access to the political process.”

“Race matters to a young man’s view of society when he spends his teenage years watching others tense up as he passes, no matter what neighborhood he grew up. Race matters to a young woman’s sense of self when she states her hometown, and then is pressed, ‘No, where are you really from?’”

You can read the full text of Sotomayor’s dissent at Politico:

There are hundreds of reactions on Twitter, from people dismayed by the ruling:

As well as people who support the SCOTUS ruling:

While the latest SCOTUS ruling is based on a Michigan law, there are currently eight states that have bans against factoring underrepresented racial groups into consideration in college admissions or job hiring. The most famous is probably California's Prop 209, which was enacted by a ballot initiative, similar to the Michigan law. Recently, the California Senate dropped a proposal to lift the ban on affirmative action programs.

However, a new Pew Research Center poll shows that 63% of Americans favor affirmative action in college admissions.

Also, check out this New York Times interactive graphic that shows how black and Hispanic students have fared in states with bans on affirmative action.

Do you think race or gender should be taken into consideration in college admissions or hiring? How do you think opportunities can be made accessible to people, in light of racism and structural inequalities? Tell us in the comments.

News and Politics Editor Grace Hwang Lynch blogs about raising an Asian mixed-race family at HapaMama.

Related Posts

Will the Supreme Court Side With Abigail Fisher in Affirmative Action Case?

A young Texan’s displeasure with not getting into her family’s alma mater has opened up a controversial topic that is mired a flurry of emotions, and a mire of contradictions. Many American colleges have a policy to encourage diversity on their campuses, but it is now up to the United States Supreme Court to decide whether affirmative action programs are levelling the playing field for minorities or unfairly punishing whites.   Read more >

Poll Pegs Black Support for Romney at Zero Percent

Pollwatchers nation-wide did a double-take Tuesday after reports of an NBC News/Wall Street Journal survey pegged African American support for that Republican presidential contender Mitt Romney at 0 percent, versus 94 percent for Pres. Barack Obama. The telephone survey queried 1000 registered voters and included about 110 black respondents. Romney also trailed Obama with among women, Hispanics and voters under 35.   Read more >

Race, Gender and Rage: My Peek Into the Twisted World of Elliot Rodger

At first glance, the UC Santa Barbara murders appear to be another senseless case of gun violence. If anything, news coverage has framed the mass killings of seven college students as a case of a white male who desperately needed psychological intervention, or perhaps as a story of a young man angry at feminism. But there is another factor besides affluence and misogyny that fueled the rage that led Elliot Rodger on his deadly spree Friday night: race.   Read more >


In order to comment on BlogHer.com, you'll need to be logged in. You'll be given the option to log in or create an account when you publish your comment. If you do not log in or create an account, your comment will not be displayed.