Why We Stopped Using Time Outs

Why We Stopped Using Time Outs

There is also an element of trust in that I do have to sometimes watch my kids make bad choices or act in ways I don’t like and trust that my values are still coming through to them and they’re going to turn out to be pretty good people. I mean, all parents have to do that no matter what parenting style they employ, but in not using punishments or rewards, you do give up some control of the day-to-day and minute-by-minute behavior, or I think Alfie Kohn would probably say illusion of control.

The funny thing is, though, giving up on the idea that I have to control every little thing they do makes me a calmer person, and becoming a calmer person makes me a better role model and a more effective parent. I actually feel even less of a need to control them because they are more willing to follow my lead without being coerced (by either punishments or “positive reinforcements”) to do so. The more I move away from coercive parenting, the more positive changes I see in my two boys, so it’s less and less a leap of faith as I begin to see the real tangible benefits of trusting them, teaching them, and working together with them instead of trying to make them do what I want them to do.

I’ve leave you with a recent example of how I handle “misbehavior” without punishment. So recent, in fact, it was just last night. At the end of the long day when we were all tired and cranky, Miles wanted to eat a third bowl of post-dinner cereal. Since it was getting close to bedtime and since he hadn’t finished the bowl I’d given him a half hour earlier, I said no, but he could have a cup of almond milk, which I gave him. He got upset and angry and banged his glass, which I told him he shouldn’t do. He got angrier and poured his milk on the floor. I acknowledged that he was very upset and calmly but firmly told him he would need to clean up the milk. Truthfully I doubted he would since he was so angry, but I continued to calmly prompt him to clean it, keeping a bit of distance so he wouldn’t feel physically intimidated.

And then he picked up a napkin and, still angry, started cleaning up the milk. I then joined in and helped him. When it was cleaned up, he was calm enough to sit in my lap and continue to cry. I held him and just let him know that I was listening. Some people would see this as “reinforcing bad behavior,” but I know that he did not WANT to get angry and cry and make a big mess, he was just overwhelmed by his feelings. He didn’t get “his way.” I still maintained my firm limit that it was too late to have another bowl of cereal, but I didn’t punish him for having an angry reaction to that. An angry kid needs my love just as much as a sad kid does, so I gave him that.

It’s not always easy to dig deep and pour love into a child who is provoking you, but when I can do that, I always feel so much better, and the kids do too.

Related Posts

April 30th Is National Spank Out Day: Does Spanking Even Work?

April 30th is National Spank Out Day. It’s hard to forget about it when the old adage “spare the rod, spoil the child” gets revisited in the news so frequently. It seems that, every week, there is a news story of parents or caregivers being arrested for taking disciplining a child too far. For all the adamant opponents of spanking, there are still just as many supporters of this purportedly mild form of corporal punishment, following the idiom to the letter.   Read more >

I Don't Like Spanking My Kids, But I Do It Anyway

I was spanked as a child. I wasn’t beaten, I wasn’t thrown around. I was laid over my fathers knee and would get a couple of good wallops. It wasn’t done excessively, only on an as-needed basis. For me, that “as-needed” would come around much more often than it would my sister. One of the small burdens of being too much like my mother. The point is, I wasn’t traumatized. I didn’t feel abused. I felt as though I deserved it and, looking back as an adult -- I did. I don’t like spanking my kids. In fact, I usually give them numerous chances and warnings to straighten out the problem before I do.   Read more >

Facebook as a Parenting Punishment Tool: Good Idea?

Denise Abbott's decision to publicly discipline her daughter on Facebook sets a precedent to be public about their issues. Technically, her 13-year-old Ava set this precedent when she first disrespected her mother online, but Denise followed suit. If the experts who say that modeling proper behavior is the best way to teach children life skills, like discretion and respect, then arguably Abbott's choice of discipline may have inadvertently reinforced her daughter's behavior instead of curbed it. Kind of like spanking a child to punish him for hitting, or screaming at a child for throwing a tantrum.   Read more >

Recent Posts by eisforerin

Comments

In order to comment on BlogHer.com, you'll need to be logged in. You'll be given the option to log in or create an account when you publish your comment. If you do not log in or create an account, your comment will not be displayed.