The Nanny Diaries: The NY Tragedy - Hug Our Kids But Don't Fire Our Nannies

The Nanny Diaries: The NY Tragedy - Hug Our Kids But Don't Fire Our Nannies

What can we do to act in solidarity with this mother? We can hug our children the way she will, for the rest of her life, wish she could.


In a world where most of us entrust our children to someone else for at least part of the day, be it a nanny or a childcare program, many of us worry about whether we are doing the right thing. As we rush out the door on Monday morning, in the light of the NY tragedy, I think most of us will look twice at the women who we are entrusting with our most precious worldly possessions, our children.

Of course, the media is all over this story...
"For working parents this is a nightmare. Every mother I know is asking today, 'How do I go back to work?'" said Denise Albert, who has two young children and lives a few blocks from the site of the tragedy.
The answer for many of us is that we HAVE to go back to work just to make ends meet. Even if one were financially privileged enough to be a full-time home-maker, no woman can be in two places at once - kid A's swim lessons that interrupt kid B's homework that conflict with Kid C's nap time. I have three children and, honestly, its a constant logistical nightmare. 

If you could have a nanny, you would, even if you aren't going to work.

The intellect in us will remind us that our nannies are possibly the least dangerous things in our home. Swimming pools, carbon monoxide, matches and the contents of our medicine cabinets are far more risky! In fact, an even sadder thought is that death at the hands of a parent is far more common than at the hands of a nanny.  However, as most mothers will report, often our intellect is overruled by our emotion, therefore, statistics will be of little help on Monday morning.

The coming days, and demanding 24 hour news cycle, will no doubt include countless women worrying about their childcare choices. It will involve a deep analysis of the nanny/family relationship and will look for 'answers' and 'warning signs'. Life isn't about controlling outcomes - that is impossible. Life is about choices given the best information and resources that I have at the time. For mothers, and fathers, those choices include who we trust to care for our children when we can't. 

The choice I make on Monday morning is to hug my kids. The world is full of mindless, senseless tragedy even when women made the best choices given the information they could.

Often there are no answers and no warning signs. By firing our nannies and questioning our childcare arrangements, especially in the media, we are NOT acting in solidarity with one mother who suffered a tragic outcome. We are adding fuel to the flames of society's expectations that women should be everything, everywhere, all the time. We are suggesting that we should make our choices with clairvoyant, 20:20 hindsight.  With all the privilege in the world, this is simply not possible.

What can we do to act in solidarity with this mother? We can hug our children the way she will, for the rest of her life, wish she could.  

Related Posts

Nanny Support: Dealing With a Sometimes-Tough Job in a Tough Time

It’s hard to even write a post like this. It’s hard to think that anyone could do such a despicable thing, to kill children, to even hurt them. And yet, this has to be said -– it has to be talked about, especially in the nanny community. Because the woman charged with this crime is one of our own.   Read more >

International Nanny Stories – from the Philippines, with Love

Yesterday, I talked about Beverly Hills Nannies and the stuff they go through with the parents they work for. And my wonderful friend Anne from the Belle Jar Blog asked me if I would talk a bit about the fact that while I may have it fairly good, many nannies in Toronto do not.These nannies are international. They are often not white. And they are here because they have no other choice.   Read more >

Working Moms Don't Choose for Their Babies to Die

She was so happy to be a mother, finally. She is one of those women that just is a mother. Even before she had children, she was a mother. Her baby died. At school, during naptime. She just fell asleep and never woke up. And my heart aches for her, for the owners of the preschool, for the teachers that were in the room with her. But the anger that I feel about the unfairness of this situation (for everyone involved), is less than what I am feeling for the unrelenting, hate mongers who commented on the news story: Women that choose to work, are choosing this for their children.   Read more >


In order to comment on, you'll need to be logged in. You'll be given the option to log in or create an account when you publish your comment. If you do not log in or create an account, your comment will not be displayed.