There are 45,000 Signatures on my Petition on Change.Org to get a Brand to stop using Images of Malnourished Models

There are 45,000 Signatures on my Petition on Change.Org to get a Brand to stop using Images of Malnourished Models

I was sitting in my office (the bathroom) flipping through the latest Vanity Fair  feeling annoyed that Julia Roberts is on the cover with legs as long as the Great Wall of China sitting on the steel-hewn lap of that aphrodisiacal Idris Elba (she's my new Gwyneth Paltrow object of jealousy) when I flipped to this ad campaign for Saint Laurent Paris.


My first reaction was, what the hell?  My second reaction was worry for this lovely young woman, because, TO ME, she looks malnourished and as the mother of two daughters I want to nourish her.

Am I crazy? Am I overreacting?

I think we've all become accustomed to seeing women whose bodies are simply animate hangers for clothing. But even with my high tolerance for ultra-thin models this one struck me as particularly cruel.

Cruel for the model if she isn't naturally thin, but depriving herself (I do not know this to be the case).

And cruel to all of the young girls and women of a certain age who'll see it, some of whom will, through osmosis, begin to believe this is the beauty standard. One they can never achieve unless they're genetically part of a small group of women (less than 2% of all men and women in America (according to CNN) who are naturally this thin.

This means 98% of women would have to deprive themselves in order to achieve this look.

Also, many readers think I was being condescending when I wrote that I want to nourish this model, but the truth is I actually am concerned for her health, because I've read far too many stories of models who have died due to complications from anorexia nervosa or who suffered silently for years while slowly starving themselves (I'll leave links below).

Hence, my petition is aimed at a business practice that fosters unhealthy working conditions.

I was inspired by a 16-year old girl who recently started a petition at to get Seventeen Magazine to stop photoshopping their models and she won!

So I've started a petition asking Yves Saint Laurent CEO, Francesca Bellettini, to stop using images of seemingly malnourished models or models with dangerously low BMI in YSL ad campaigns.

You can CLICK ON THIS LINK to sign the petition and share your views on the subject of what I call advertising's War On Women.

If this goes well I'd really like to begin a movement to get all advertisers to use healthy women for their campaigns, one ad campaign at a time.  Please share this one if you have the time. It's important and we can make a difference. Thank you in advance! To keep abreast of my body image efforts sign up for our newsletter NOW!

This article by Carre Otis about her struggle with anorexia (and near death) is a must: Living With Anorexia: Carrie Otis.

Related Posts

Trust Women: Save Reproductive Health Clinics in Kansas

Harassment by both anti-choice legislation and extremist terrorism has lead to the closure of all but three reproductive health clinics in Kansas that offer abortions. Now many women have to drive hours to reach one of the few remaining places to get any abortion procedure. It's a barrier to access that anti-choicers use to undermine a woman's right to control her own body upheld by Roe v. Wade -- and for many Kansas women, it means that they cannot, in reality, exercise their reproductive rights.   Read more >

How Facebook Can Really Help Women Connect

Taking action to further gender justice is admirable, but some people see Facebook's internal actions as out of step with this stated mission. The top comment to greet me on the Women Connect page, ranked up through users hitting the "Like" button, reads: "I'm glad that FB is supporting this but they also need to get their own house in order - for example by taking down misogynist & pro-rape pages and dropping their stupid censorship against images of breastfeeding."   Read more >

Why Hasn't a Woman Moderated a General Election Presidential Debate in 20 Years?

In 1992, the United States of America witnessed three general election presidential debates. Jim Lehrer of PBS moderated the first and third; Carole Simpson of ABC News moderated the second. My son was still in diapers then; he'll be 22 later this year. Then, my daughter was just a tween; today she's past 30, old enough to have a tween of her own. So, it's been 20 years since a woman moderated a general election presidential debate. That doesn't sound right, I thought, when a petition landed in my email generated by three female sophomores at Montclair High School in New Jersey: Emma Axelrod, Sammi Siegel, and Elena Tsemberis.   Read more >


In order to comment on, you'll need to be logged in. You'll be given the option to log in or create an account when you publish your comment. If you do not log in or create an account, your comment will not be displayed.